Why Gender and Gender Identity Matter to Mental Health (Part 3)

In the fall of 2024, the Benediction Counseling team read the book Difference Matters: Communicating Social Identity by Brenda Allen and participated in formal trainings by experts in each content area. Throughout Difference Matters, Allen encourages readers to recognize the power of understanding and respecting diversity. Each chapter invites reflection on how we can challenge dominant narratives, broaden our perspectives, and cultivate empathy. The book’s hopeful message is that, through awareness and active engagement, we can create inclusive spaces where everyone feels valued and supported. This 9-part blog series is part book review and part integration to understand the implications of each social identity on the field of mental health. Please join us on this journey to become culturally informed providers!

Book Summary: Difference Matters: Communicating Social Identity by Brenda Allen.
In this chapter, Allen explores gender as a complex, socially constructed identity with far-reaching implications. Gender matters because it shapes how individuals are treated, what is expected of them, and the opportunities available to them. The dominant narrative often upholds traditional gender roles and binary expectations, limiting individuals and perpetuating inequality. The corrective experience encourages recognizing gender as a spectrum, respecting diverse gender identities, and challenging restrictive gender norms. By embracing gender diversity, we create a society that honors each person’s identity and supports their freedom to live authentically.

Why Gender Identity Matters to Mental Health
Narrowly-defined gender expectations can lead to mental health challenges, as restrictive roles and societal pressures impact self-image and self-acceptance. For those whose gender identity differs from societal norms—such as nonbinary or transgender individuals—misunderstanding and discrimination can lead to increased risks of anxiety, depression, and trauma-related symptoms. The rate of suicidal ideation and suicide attempts are much higher among transgender individuals, indicating a mental health crisis related to systemic oppression and violence toward this population. Traditional gender roles may also increase stress in people of all genders, as they navigate societal expectations that don’t align with their authentic selves. Approaching gender identity with respect for gender diversity and individual empowerment can provide a powerful foundation for positive mental health and self-acceptance.