Why Identity, Difference, and Power Matter to Mental Health (Part 1)

In the fall of 2024, the Benediction Counseling team read the book Difference Matters: Communicating Social Identity by Brenda Allen and participated in formal trainings by experts in each content area. Throughout Difference Matters, Allen encourages readers to recognize the power of understanding and respecting diversity. Each chapter invites reflection on how we can challenge dominant narratives, broaden our perspectives, and cultivate empathy. The book’s hopeful message is that, through awareness and active engagement, we can create inclusive spaces where everyone feels valued and supported. This 9-part blog series is part book review and part integration to understand the implications of each social identity on the field of mental health. Please join us on this journey to become culturally informed providers!
Book Summary: Difference Matters: Communicating Social Identity by Brenda Allen.
​Allen opens with key definitions and frameworks around identity, difference, and power because understanding these concepts is essential for recognizing how individual experiences are shaped by social structures. The dominant social group in any category defines the narrative about that identity. The risk inherent in allowing the dominant group to define what is “best” and “healthy” for all groups is that it is not informed by the impact of all social identities on people’s lives. The corrective experience involves acknowledging one’s own identity, recognizing privilege, becoming aware of marginalization and becoming open to learning about diverse lived experiences. By embracing these principles, readers can foster greater empathy and build inclusive communities.
Why Identity, Difference and Power Matters to Mental Health
Understanding identity, difference, and power has a substantial impact on mental health. Defining one’s social identities can be liberating, as it provides context for our personal experiences. Understanding one’s proximity to the dominant narrative is important. For those in privileged groups, they are often supported by the dominant narrative and can bring healing to their communities when they learn from those with differing lived experiences and combat oppressive systems. For those in marginalized groups, the dominant narrative creates a power imbalance that can cause feelings of isolation, invalidation, and internalized shame, affecting self-worth and self-esteem. Creating awareness of oppressive systems can allow more accurate self-reflection, personal choice and self-compassion.